Thursday, September 10, 2009

Sprawl: a problem without a solution?

I got this great article from and wanted to share it with you:

Adam Stein | September 3, 2009

New study suggest we need to look elsewhere to curb carbon emissions

Dueling headlines cropped up in my newsreader today:

More People, Less Driving: The Imperative of Curbing Sprawl (Smart Growth America)


Forget Curbing Suburban Sprawl: Building denser cities would do little to reduce CO2 emissions, a new NAS report concludes (MIT Technology Review)

Both articles refer to the same study, conducted by a blue-ribbon panel for the U.S. Department of Energy. And both are pretty much right: the study does affirm the link between sprawl and carbon emissions, but it also strongly suggests that attacking sprawl is a tough way to curb energy use.

Despite the common-sense link between density and driving, establishing cause and effect in a rigorous manner remains difficult. The sheer number of variables tend to overwhelm the analysis. Nevertheless, empirical evidence does support a link between land use and vehicle miles traveled (VMT). The MIT Technology Review summarizes the study’s conclusion thusly:

Even if 75 percent of all new and replacement housing in America were built at twice the density of current new developments, and those living in the newly constructed housing drove 25 percent less as a result, CO2 emissions from personal travel would decline nationwide by only 8 to 11 percent by 2050, according to the study. If just 25 percent of housing units were developed at such densities and residents drove only 12 percent less as a result, CO2 emissions would be reduced by less than 2 percent by 2050.

In other words, an enormous shift in land development trends yields a roughly 10% cut in emissions over 40 years. A more modest shift in land development trends yields a fairly anemic drop in emissions over 40 years. Vehicle fuel efficiency provides a much bigger lever for lowering emissions from transportation. This is what I was getting at the other day when I said, “If your car runs on electricity, and your electricity comes from the sun, and your McMansion is built to the Passive House standard, then your suburban lifestyle is suddenly looking a lot more benign.”

All that being the case, the study sensibly recommends a variety of policies to promote compact, mixed-use development. There are a number of good reasons to pursue smart land use policies, even if attacking sprawl isn’t likely to save us from climate change in the near- or even medium-term.

The first is that many anti-sprawl measures are just good policy in their own right. Carbon taxes, gas taxes, transit development, better zoning laws, etc., all make sense regardless of their immediate payback in reduced gasoline consumption. And, of course, sprawl has environmental impacts beyond just VMT.

The second is that we’re stuck with our built environment for a very long time, so if we want the future to look different than the past, we had better get started making some changes. As Ryan Avent reminds us, “Between now and mid-century, the country will very nearly have to build itself all over again to accommodate population growth. In addition to the 100 million homes now in America, somewhere between 62 and 105 million more will be built.” Examples such as Portland show that it is possible to buck the dominant trend in development. But it takes a few decades for the results to really show.


Anonymous said...

[url=]juegos casino [/url]
[url=]the palm casino resort [/url]
[url=]atlantic city casino map [/url]
[url=]casino sobrenatural [/url]
[url=]jeux casino [/url]
[url=]aruba grand beach resort casino [/url]
[url=]casino game [/url]
[url=]gran casino bilbao menu cena [/url]
[url=]you know my name casino [/url]
[url=]casinos online en espana [/url]
[url=]online casino gambling guide [/url]
[url=]casino guide http 24hr onlinecasinos com [/url]
[url=]groupe casino [/url]
[url=]excalibur casino [/url]
[url=]gambling casino online [/url]
torneo poker casino madrid
[b]nd casino forum[/b]
casino betting tool
casino de benidorm
[b]atlantic city hilton casino[/b]
casino forum
[u]playa casino brasil[/u]
best online casino affiliate program
casino gaming betting
[b]casinos web com co[/b]
banda sonora casino royal
eurobet casino bonus

Anonymous said...


[url=]wholesale cigarettes with a money order [/url]
ordering cigarettes from overseas cigarettes black market where to buy buy cigarettes in new hampshire
[url=]buy cigarettes in north [/url]
buy camel blue cigarettes buy canadian cigarettes online cigarettes discount buying shopping
[url=]place to buy herbal cigarettes [/url]
buy cigarettes info buy cigarettes online from kentucky buy ecstasy cigarettes
[url=]electronic cigarette buy [/url]
where to buy cigarette tobacco electric cigarettes buy ordering cigarettes from canada
[url=]cigarette ordering [/url]
buy advance lights online cigarettes cannabis cigarettes buy buy cigarettes from mexico
[url=]buy cigarette canada [/url]
buy marlboro cigarettes online cheap buy cigarettes online south carolina buy cigarettes california
[url=]buy vantage cigarette online [/url]
buy electronic cigarette uk mail order cigarettes canada buy belmont cigarettes
[url=]splash cigarettes buy online [/url]
how many people buy cigaretts buy cigarettes over internet buying cigarettes online how to
[url=]order cigarette [/url]
cigarette holder cary nc buy purchase buy cigarettes from japan buy cigarettes made
[url=]legal to buy cigarettes online [/url]
buy flavored cigarette to buy cigarettes buy carlton cigarettes online